Thursday, November 7, 2013

Preliminary Findings about Ecological Sanitation in North Bihar, India

In June and July 2013, Janis Koknevics conducted interviews in three separate districts (Paschim (West) Champaran, Saharsa, and Khagaria) in the state of Bihar, in India, investigating the sustainability of ecosan units promoted and installed by Megh Pyne Abhiyan (MPA) an NGO associated with SATNET Asia. 

A village in the Khagaria district was the last study site for Mr. Koknevics, located in a district surrounded by large river systems, which lead to regular floods, loss of property and life. In this village, MPA installed 40 ecosan units, and a total of 24 households were interviewed. The majority of ecosan units observed where built with a brick/cement sub-structure and bamboo/mud super-structure while three units were fully brick/cement built. Several supplementary or temporarily unused units were utilized for storage of corn stalks, water filters, and straw bundles or for drying clothes. 

Ecosan users stated benefits of saving one to three hours/day not having to go for open defecation, using that time for household chores, cooking and relaxing. Safety of the family was noted as being very important and regular access to the ecosan as beneficial, especially during sickness and monsoon. Six households stated having used urine at least once for their crops, and observing greener, stronger crops. 

Issues observed and reported by respondents were broken water pipes, the presence of water in the excreta chambers (leading to bad smell), blocked urine pipes, and erosion of the soil supporting the structures. 

In conclusion, the technology does provide security, saves time, reduces fertilizer costs and increases hygiene awareness in the households that have adopted it. Also, training adopters on the use and maintenance of the units is necessary for long term use. Mr Koknevics believes it is a suitable technology if an awareness program goes hand in hand with the implementation of this technology.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Results from the sustainability assessment of riverbed farming in Nepal



In spring 2013, Ms. Katharina Schiller (MSc student, University of Hohenheim) investigated the sustainability of leasehold riverbed vegetable farming in the Terai of Nepal. She interviewed landless and land-poor farmers in Kailali and Kanchanpur districts in Far-Western Nepal. These farmers leased a minimum of 1354 m² (4 kattha, local land area unit) of seasonally dry riverbed from the community or private land owners to produce cucumbers, bottle and bitter gourds, pumpkins, and watermelons for market sale.
Riverbed farming group in Hasuliya, Nepal
On average, riverbed farmers earned US$ 236.46 (NPR 20,808.24) from 1354 m² of land, with 3 members of the household contributing farm labor. Thus, riverbed farming enabled households to gain extra income as well as created opportunities for employment of household members. 70% of households reported a reduction in male out-migration in search of work to Nepalese or Indian urban centers. Extra income is spent on children's education, food, and household needs. Farmers from groups that have been farming the riverbed for five years or more have been able to accumulate enough capital to diversify their income opportunities. Some farmers are investing in market center shops, such as cell phone repair shops; several are leasing increasingly large tracts of riverbed and hiring local wage laborers to till it, creating additional rural employment opportunities for other village households. One farmer's husband opened a roadside restaurant, ingenious since it creates both an immediate market and a value-added component for the produce.
Riverbed farming is an agricultural technology with minimal negative environmental impact. It uses no energy besides human labor, irrigation is necessary only if vegetables are grown on riverbanks, not in the riverbeds, and it doesn't disturb the neighborhood with dust or noise. Since the rivers change course often, requiring new beds to be dug, and farmers use comparatively small amounts of chemical inputs. By covering the sandy riverbeds, riverbed farming contributes to mitigating sandy dust in the air (reduction of sand erosion). Also, the use of marginal land such as riverbeds eases production pressure on arable land.
Also, riverbed farming has several positive features. According to interviewed farmers, riverbed farming is an easy-to-learn approach. Since it is based on lease of the riverbeds, it doesn't have large start-up costs in terms of physical capital required. Different types of spill-over effects were observed: The technology has been independently replicated in several places by neighbors or in neighboring villages. It was observed that not only the farmers themselves but also other family members and neighbors gathered to listen during information sessions with Local Resource Persons. Additionally, riverbed farmers are applying their new skills, such as the use of compost or mulching, in their home gardens as well.
All these criteria are taken into account for calculating a composite sustainability indicator of riverbed farming when comparing it with other technologies that the SATNET Asia project has collected with the help of its associates and network members.
Opportunities for the future support of riverbed farmers include facilitating a stronger infrastructure so farmers enjoy easier access to markets for both input buying and produce sales. A few groups traded surplus vegetables for grains and goods within the village, but most farmers reported travel times of 1-2 hours by foot, bicycle or buffalo-drawn cart to the nearest market center to buy seeds or sell their produce. Ensuring access to seeds early in the growing season is crucial: an early planting enables an early harvest, which fetches a much higher market price than during high season, when the marketplace is glutted with vegetables both local and from neighboring India. Another option to aid an early harvest is the construction of a group seedling nursery in winter, so vegetables can be planted in early spring. Other opportunities lie in the creation of savings or crop insurance cooperatives to mitigate short-term environmental risk, introducing Integrated Pest Management strategies to reduce use of pesticides and contribute to increasing biodiversity, offering additional business training sessions to help farmers diversify their income opportunities, creating stronger linkages to other local projects (like community seed banks in neighboring areas), and more farmer-to-farmer meetings for knowledge sharing.

Thursday, July 25, 2013

Ecological sanitation in North Bihar helps farmers save time and increases yields


Picture 1: Ecosan toilet with mud, straw and bamboo super structure.
Mr Janis Koknevics, a master student in Agricultural Sciences in the tropics and sub tropics from the University of Hohenheim is currently in northern Bihar, India, investigating the sustainability of the ecological sanitation (ecosan) units. The ecosan units are promoted and implemented by Megh Pyne Abhiyan (MPA), a local NGO and associate in SATNET Asia. For this study Mr. Koknevics is visiting 3 districts where MPA works, namely, Paschim (West) Champaran, Saharsa, and Khagaria.

Access to sanitation in rural Bihar is very limited and open defecation is common practice. The state of Bihar is also a flood prone area with over 70% of the total geographical area flood affected. During floods, unsafe sanitation practices contribute to water borne diseases and lead to increased use of land on high ground (i.e. embankments) for open defecation, further exacerbating the conditions in which people are forced to live in.
Picture 2: Inside of ecosan toilet: hole for urine (center), for defecating (with covers) and for cleaning oneself after the toilet (extreme right and left). Ash to apply onto the excreta (right  corner).





The broad technical aspects of the ecosan units, also called “Phaydemand Shauchalay”, meaning beneficial or productive toilet, is to provide a safe structure, separating urine, excreta and wash water. The technology is designed to withstand floods, with a brick/cement base structure, containing 2 excreta chambers, one urine outlet and 2 anal wash water outlets. When one excreta chamber is full, it is sealed and left to decompose over a period of 6 months or more, while the 2nd excreta chamber is used. Urine is directly collected in a gallon container, or in a separate chamber fitted with a tap for easy access.
Since arriving in India Mr. Koknevics has met with local water and sanitation experts in Delhi, MPA representatives in Bihar, stakeholders at local government level, local NGO representatives, as well as farmers and ecosan users in the respective districts. Mr. Koknevics conducted questionnaire based face-to-face interviews with ecosan users.
Picture 3: Full brick and cement structure in Rupaliya. The drawing painted on the ecosan toilet demonstrates the cycle from defecating to applying urine and humanure to crops.
Ecosan users stated benefits of saving 1 to 2 hours/day by not having to go for open defecation, time which is now used for household (HH) chores, farming, education or relaxing. Safety of the family was also mentioned as both a benefit and reason for adoption of the ecosan toilet. The use of urine as a fertilizer has been positively received in the village, with farmers observing greener crops and higher yields through individual experiments at HH level by applying urine to some crops and chemical fertilizers to others. Use of urine has led farmers purchasing less urea (1-2 bags) and these savings being used for purchasing clothes and other HH utensils. The use and application of humanure (decomposed human excreta) was not yet commonly adopted in all villages. However, one respondent stated using humanure in his fields and observed “greener crops and no issues with insects”.
The main maintenance issue that was observed and identified by a majority of respondents was the presence of worms in the excreta chambers, with respondents stating children having difficulties with urinating and defecating separately and water entering the excreta chamber accidentally when washing oneself. In one village, respondents reported missing or broken gas pipes (meant for evacuating smell from the excreta chambers), urine taps missing or broken and one HH had no roof for the toilet
Mr. Koknevics looks forward to providing more detailed information by the end of his stay in Bihar.

Tuesday, July 9, 2013

Reaching farmers in Pakistan with sustainable agricultural technologies

A training workshop on identifying sustainable agricultural technologies and translating research findings into information accessible to extension workers and farmers took place from 1 to 5 July 2013 in Islamabad, Pakistan. The workshop was organized in partnership between the Centre for Alleviation of Poverty through Sustainable Agriculture (CAPSA), Pakistan Agricultural Research Council (PARC), National Agricultural Research Centre (NARC) and Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). It gathered about 23 scientists from PARC institutes around the country and three people from FAO, Pakistan office.

The workshop focused on four important parts of development work in Pakistan – (i) learning to conduct sustainability assessments of agricultural technologies; (ii) improving communication by understanding knowledge needs of different types of stakeholders as a way of addressing the gap between research and practice; (iii) sharing knowledge through targeted knowledge products such as technology factsheets.

The key outcomes generated from the training include the following:

  • Participants constructed exemplary hierarchy schemes for indicator construction for five technologies.
  • Participants compiled available data needed for indicator calculation for two technologies that are being promoted in Pakistan – zero-tillage and home gardens. 
  • Participants produced an excel sheet for data entry and indicator calculation containing all needed formulas and calculated sustainability indicators for the two technologies mentioned above.
  • Participants prepared 17 factsheets by following the template for factsheets that has been developed by SATNET Asia.
  • The SATNET Asia Network expanded as it now includes all 23 researchers that attended the training.
  • Strengthened collaboration with PARC, NARC and FAO in Pakistan.
The factsheets cover the following topics:

  •  Managing salinity in the Indus Basin using skimming wells with pressurized irrigation technologies
  •  Advancing cucumber crop by early nursery raising
  • Farmers’ rice bank
  •  Integrated pest management model for fruit flies in Pakistan
  • Green Panic – a valuable grass for improving productivity of ranges of Potohar Plateau
  •  Participatory goat breed improvement
  • Post-harvest technology of deciduous fruit crops
  • Popularizing nutritionally-balanced cattle feed for increasing productivity of dairy farms in Pakistan 
  • New high yielding tomato varieties for Gilgit Baltistan
  • Boron application increases cotton yield in Pakistan
  • Micro-irrigation system
  • Cultivation of medicinal plants on marginal lands of Cholistan Desert through training of farmers
  • Home gardening for eco-friendly healthy diet and pesticide risk free vegetables
  • A new high yielding oat variety for rainfed Potohar and irrigated areas of Pakistan
  • Biological control of sugarcane borers by using insect natural enemy
  • Phytoremediation technology
  • The FMI seeder and its performance
The workshop facilitators used a number of processes to encourage participants’ learning and knowledge sharing. Participants’ feedback showed that whether they engaged in individual or group work, analytical or writing exercises, peer reviews, role playing or various discussions, everybody contributed to the training and left home enriched.  “We learned what sustainability is and how to assess it based on indicators. Once I identify a sustainable technology, I now know how to communicate it,” shared one of the participants during the final reflection.